The Due Diligence Gauntlet: How to Prepare Your Financials to Satisfy Sophisticated Buyers

(PE Firms & Strategic Acquirers)

Selling your business for maximum value isn’t about finding a buyer; it’s about surviving the scrutiny of the right buyer.

When sophisticated acquirers—like Private Equity (PE) firms or large strategic competitors—show interest, they don’t just glance at your financials. They perform a forensic-level X-ray. This is the “Due Diligence Gauntlet.”

In our Charting Opportunities series, we’ve had experts like Jay Ripley of GEM discuss how PE firms evaluate companies. They are not looking for a “good story”; they are looking for verifiable, high-quality data. Any unproven claim, sloppy record, or financial anomaly isn’t just a question mark. It’s a financial negotiation point they will use to lower your price.

Being prepared for this gauntlet is the single most effective way to protect your valuation, build buyer confidence, and accelerate your path to a successful exit. This post is your preparation guide.

Why “Good Enough” Books Will Kill Your Deal

As a business owner, you’ve likely maintained your books for two reasons: running the business and satisfying the IRS. This “good enough” approach works for operations, but it will kill your deal when you try to sell.

A sophisticated buyer’s mindset is entirely different. They are scanning your data for two things: Risk and Opportunity. Your financials are their primary map to find both.

Here is what they are really scrutinizing:

• Quality of Earnings (QoE): This is the holy grail. They will dig deep to determine if your reported EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization) is real, repeatable, and sustainable.
• The “Add-Backs”: They will challenge every owner benefit you claim. That family member on the payroll, the personal vehicle lease, the one-time legal fee you want to “add back” to profits? Each one must be proven as non-recurring and non-essential to the business.
• Hidden Liabilities: Are there unrecorded debts, pending lawsuits, or unresolved state tax issues? They will find them.
• Customer Concentration: They will analyze your revenue to see how much comes from one or two clients. If your top customer walks, does the business collapse?
• Scalability: Do the numbers prove the business can run—and grow—without you personally in the driver’s seat?

Your 5-Point Financial Fortress

This is the core “how-to.” To protect your valuation, you must build this financial fortress before you ever sign a Letter of Intent (LOI).

1. Pristine, Accrual-Based Financials: Move beyond “cash-basis” QuickBooks. You need three to five years of clean, accrual-based financial statements (P&L, Balance Sheet, and Cash Flow). If your books aren’t formally audited, have them reviewed by a credible, third-party CPA firm. This shows you are serious and transparent.
2. The Indisputable EBITDA Calculation: Don’t just have a number; have a schedule. Your “Normalized” or “Adjusted” EBITDA must be a detailed calculation. Every single add-back must be documented with a paper trail (e.g., “Owner’s auto lease: $1,200/mo. Here is the lease agreement.”).
3. A “Bottom-Up” Financial Forecast: Buyers will ignore a simple “we’ll grow 10% next year” projection. You need a forecast built from the bottom up. How many new customers, at what average price point, driven by which specific sales activities, and at what cost? This proves you understand your own business drivers.
4. A Clean Bill of Health (Contracts & Compliance): This isn’t just financials; it’s the data that supports them. Have all key customer contracts, employee agreements, and vendor/lease documents organized in a digital data room. Ensure all your state and local tax (SALT) filings are current and correct.
5. The Ultimate Weapon: The “Sell-Side” QoE Report. This is the pro move. Instead of waiting for the buyer to pick you apart, you hire your own M&A advisory firm to perform a “Quality of Earnings” report on your business before you go to market. This lets you find every skeleton in your own closet, fix it, and control the narrative from day one.

The Red Flags That Invite “Re-Trading”

Re-what?

“Re-trading” is the dreaded moment when a buyer uses a “discovery” from due diligence to lower their offer price. Here are the red flags that practically beg a buyer to re-trade.

• Red Flag 1: Co-mingling Funds: Using the business account for personal expenses. It’s the number one sign of an unsophisticated operation and instantly erodes trust.
• Red Flag 2: Customer Concentration: A single client representing 40% or more of your revenue. A buyer sees this as a massive risk and will discount your value accordingly.
• Red Flag 3: The “Hockey Stick” Projection: A sudden, unexplainable spike in your revenue forecast that doesn’t match your historical performance. It signals desperation or delusion.
• Red Flag 4: Weak or Missing Contracts: Relying on handshake deals. If a revenue stream isn’t secured by a written contract, a buyer will assume that revenue is at risk of disappearing.
• Red Flag 5: The “Owner-Dependent” Business: If all client relationships and critical operational knowledge are in your head, the buyer sees the company’s value walking out the door with you.

From Gauntlet to Glide Path

The due diligence gauntlet is designed to be stressful. It’s a test. But like any test, you can study for it.

A clean, organized, and defensible set of financials turns the gauntlet from an interrogation into a simple confirmation. It builds trust, removes friction, and is your single best defense against a last-minute price cut.

Preparing for an exit starts two to three years before you plan to sell. If you’re a business owner, the time to start cleaning your books and building your financial fortress is now. Contact Portus Wealth Advisors today to get the process started with a team of professionals who travel this path every day with all entrepreneur clients we serve.

(704) 936-0084