How to Spot a Fake Expert Before They Cost You Money
William’s dad was an extraordinarily proud no-sock-wearing person. Nobody knows exactly where it started. Maybe a trip to Boston or somewhere in the Northeast for training back in the day, where he picked up the style and brought it home for good. Whatever the origin, it became his thing. There are pictures of him coaching youth soccer in shorts and loafers, no socks, pushing a puddle of water out of the goal box with a giant broom so the game could go on.
It was authentic. It was genuinely who he was.
Fast forward to a dinner out with his wife recently, where William spotted a well-dressed gentleman at the next table who appeared to be doing the same thing. No socks. A little smile, a little nod to his dad’s memory. Except a few minutes later William looked again and realized the man was, in fact, wearing socks. Hidden socks, tucked down just far enough into the shoe to create the illusion of going sockless without actually committing to it.
His dad would have been deeply disappointed.
Fashionable vs. Authentic
That small observation opened up a much bigger question. How much of what we see in the world today is people genuinely doing something versus people doing it because it looks good?
The no-sock trend is harmless enough. But the same pattern shows up in the professional world in ways that are anything but harmless. Business owners regularly end up working with attorneys, insurance agents, M&A brokers, and other advisors who present themselves as specialists in something they only dabble in. They say they do it. They have done it a handful of times. But it is not what they do every day, it is not where their real expertise lives, and the difference shows up when it matters most.
Why It’s So Hard to Spot a Fake Expert
Here is the uncomfortable truth about spotting a fake expert before they cost you money. It is genuinely difficult. When someone tells you they do something, the natural and reasonable instinct is to take them at their word. Verifying expertise takes time, effort, and sometimes a level of knowledge you don’t have yet in the area you are trying to fill.
That is exactly what makes the hidden socks analogy so useful. From a distance, hidden socks look identical to no socks. You have to look closely, more than once, before you see the difference. The same is true with professionals who look the part but aren’t actually delivering at the level they advertise.
What to Look For
The best signals of genuine expertise are the ones that are hardest to fake. How often do they actually do this specific type of work? Who else have they done it for and can you talk to those people? Do they ask the kind of questions that reveal deep familiarity with the nuances of your situation or do they stay at a surface level that could apply to anyone?
Authentic professionals are usually easy to identify once you know what you are looking for. They are specific where generalists are vague. They push back where someone trying to impress you would just agree. They tell you what they cannot do as readily as they tell you what they can.
Building the Right Team
For business owners, the advisory team around you is one of the most important assets you have. The right attorney, the right CPA, the right M&A advisor, the right wealth manager. Each one of those relationships has real consequences for the outcomes you achieve.
Don’t settle for hidden socks. Look for the real thing.
Join the Conversation:
Want to go deeper?
Portus Perspectives is part of a broader conversation. Join William and the Portus team each month for Charting Opportunities — in-depth discussions with founders, exit experts, and business specialists.
ORIGINAL MEDIA SOURCE(S):
William Bissett: What’s Authentic About Not Wearing Socks? | Portus Perspectives
Originally Recorded on June 15, 2026
Portus Perspectives: Episode 26